house that it was ready for business, and another to
report rules. The house appointed T. B. Hartzell as
sergeant-at-arms, and seven assistants, and instructed them
to bring in absentee members. On the second day the
accession of Cropsey, Linch, and Tennant, with the loss of
Sheldon and Smith, raised the number of senators to eight.
The house reported twenty absent, which meant one less than
a quorum present. But trickery and fraud quite commonly
defeat themselves. On the 17th the senate passed a bill
providing for the filling of vacancies in executive offices.
But it was now easy to discern that this ill-considered
scheme was a failure, and as rats desert the sinking ship,
the members who came were not inclined to stay. On the 19th
the opposition played its trump. On the arrest of Senator
Tennant by the sergeant-at-arms, to compel his attendance, a
writ of habeas corpus was applied for in the supreme court.
At the hearing on the 21st, the testimony of Acting Governor
James, his private secretary, and Senator Hascall was taken.
In the report of the case it is stated that, "Hascall, who
resided in Omaha, learning of James's absence, went at once
to Lincoln, the capital, and under pretense that the
document was one certifying that some person was a 'notary
public, obtained from James's private secretary the great
seal, long enough to get its impress to a paper of which the
following (the proclamation) is a copy, and which was
published in some of the papers of the state."
Eleazer Wakeley and Mark H. Sessions,
counsel for Tennant, adopted and emphasized the theory that
Hascall had not assumed the office of governor, according to
the spirit and form contemplated by the constitution. He had
not acted in good faith, but had clandestinely slipped into
the governor's office and, under a false pretense,
appropriated and used the seal for this single specific
purpose. Judge Lake leaned to this view in his opinion; but
Crounse did not commit himself on that point. Both of these
judges, however, contended that the executive had complete
control of the proclamation up to the time when it had
become finally effective, and that, having recalled it, the
legislature was not in legal session, had no authority to
compel the attendance of members, and so its "every act is
without the shadow of authority." Judge Mason, in his
dissenting opinion, made the very strong point that the
regularity of the procedure, preliminary to the assembling
of the legislature, could not be questioned collaterally; it
had resulted in a session, at least de facto, of a
coördinate department of the government of which the
other departments were bound to take judicial notice. The
chief justice also strenuously maintained that Hascall's
call became vitalized beyond revocation the moment that it
was issued. He plausibly more than hinted that the majority
was governed by political bias. "Courts should yield to no
clamor, and shrink from no responsibility," he said. Justice
Crounse protested against Mason's insinuations in a curt
note appended to the opinions, in which he said that his
opinion and that of Judge Lake were given hastily at the
time of the hearing, while Mason had taken time for
investigation before preparing his own.
Decisions of questions with a political
bearing by mere majorities in our courts, high and low, are
so common, that Judge Mason's strictures need not excite our
wonder. It seems relevant to note that the domicile of the
two agreeing judges was in the North Platte, and that of the
dissenter was in the South Platte. There is ground for
perpetual dispute as to whether the contention of the
majority or that of the minority is the better sustained by
reason. The effect of the decision was at least salutary in
summarily circumventing the cheap trickery of Hascall and
relieving the state from another scandalous exhibition of
imbecility. For it is not probable that a working quorum
could have been kept together. The attitude of the press is
as clearly explicable as the opinions of the learned judges
are indeterminate and confusing. The Lincoln organ was of
course in favor of a session, and so the
Tribune-Republican at Omaha was of course violently
opposed to it. The Bee, just then fighting for a
foothold in the Omaha journalistic field, was against its
local rival, and so supported Hascall. The episode moved the
nearly republican organ in the neighboring
|